Troy and Troyes – Robert Tye

The British Numismatic Society constitutionally operates “for the benefit of the public through the encouragement and promotion of numismatic science”. I wonder therefore if there are any members who share my concerns about the current state of public understanding of the metrological aspect of numismatics? I ask because a great rift has appeared between the published British scholarly accounts of the history of English weight standards and what the general public is today being led to believe about that same thing.

2 thoughts on “Troy and Troyes – Robert Tye”

  1. Dear Robert,

    If you ask ChatGPT about the origin of the Troy ounce then you do indeed get the Troyes explanation. However if you ask a follow up question such as “Are you really sure about that – what about the link to grains?” then you get a much more nuanced answer.

    I suppose that the lack of response to your articles is probably not a lack of interest but more a lack of relevance. Most people who work with precious metals probably just accept the weight for what it is and don’t really care about the origin. Its actually quite remarkable that ancient weights such as troy ounces, tolas and carats (all based on seeds) have survived into the present era given the zeal with which reformers like to decimalise everything.

Leave a Reply